Netflix vs. Paramount: The fight for Warner Bros

The current situation: A tale of two offers

For anyone catching up, here is the situation on the ground. Last Friday, Netflix made a move that many expected eventually but perhaps not this soon. They announced a friendly deal to acquire WBD’s studios and HBO for roughly $27.75 per share. The total value of this deal is approximately $82.7 billion.

It sounded like a strong move until you read the fine print. The deal is a mix of cash and stock, and it leaves behind the "linear" TV channels like CNN and TNT in a spin-off that shareholders would have to manage separately.

Then, just yesterday, Paramount (backed by Skydance) entered the picture with a "hostile" offer that changed the dynamic entirely. They offered $30.00 per share in all cash for the entire company. This brings the total valuation to a massive $108.4 billion.

Now we have a standoff. On one side, there is a strategic partner in Netflix offering a premium brand association. On the other, a competitor is offering immediate liquidity and a higher headline price.

Why cash is winning the argument

When I look at the numbers, the Paramount bid appears much stronger fundamentally. In the current market environment, uncertainty is a significant risk. The Netflix deal is pegged to their stock price. If Netflix shares decline, which they have been doing since the news broke, the value of their offer declines with it. Furthermore, spin-offs are operationally difficult. They take months to execute, and the value of the new "spun-off" company is often unpredictable.

Paramount, on the other hand, is offering a clean exit. $30.00 is a fixed number. There is no complex new company to form and no stock volatility to worry about. From my perspective, that simplicity is a massive advantage. It forces the WBD board to consider whether they can justify rejecting a higher, all-cash offer in favor of a lower, more complex deal with Netflix.

The regulatory and political angle

There is another factor that I believe shifts the odds, and that is the regulatory environment. 

First, the competition problem. Netflix is already the biggest name in streaming. If they buy HBO, they would control a huge chunk of the market. Regulators usually block deals that create monopolies like that. President Trump has already publicly criticised the deal, noting that their market dominance "could be a problem" for competition.

Paramount has a much smoother path, and a lot of that comes down to politics. Skydance is backed by the Ellison family, who are major donors to President Trump. On top of that, reports confirm that Jared Kushner’s investment firm is helping fund the deal. In situations like this, having the administration on your side is a huge advantage.

Finally, there is the foreign investment backup. You might wonder where Paramount is getting $108 billion in cash. Filings show the money is coming from government funds in Saudi Arabia, Abu Dhabi, and Qatar. Usually, the U.S. government gets nervous about foreign money, but Paramount was smart about it. They made these investors "silent partners," meaning they have no voting rights and no control. To make it even safer, the Chinese company Tencent completely dropped out of the deal. Paramount effectively dodged all the major legal traps.

How I think this plays out

Currently, WBD is trading around the $28.26 mark as of yesterday's close. This tells me the market is still skeptical and is pricing in some risk that neither deal happens, or that the process drags on. The price is sitting between the two offers, higher than the Netflix bid but lower than the Paramount bid.

However, based on the current data, I believe Paramount eventually wins this.

The pressure on the board will likely be too high to ignore. Shareholders tend to prefer immediate value, and an all-cash premium is difficult to vote against. I would not be surprised if Netflix attempts to improve their offer, perhaps by adding more cash, but they likely have a ceiling because of the regulatory risks involved.

Right now, it is a waiting game. If the stock price starts climbing toward that $30 offer, it is a strong sign that big investors believe the deal will go through. But if the price gets stuck here? It means the fight is far from over. Either way, we are at a turning point, and the next move will be huge.

‍